Welcome to Gaia! :: View User's Journal | Gaia Journals

 
 

View User's Journal

Report This Entry Subscribe to this Journal
ZeekSlider's Monthly Collectable Item Critiques
Honest opinions about the items you care about!
August 2005 Donation Item Critique
This month's Donation Items are the Whip of Fire and the Whip of Ice.

User Image
Quote:
Must Have Rating: 3 out of 5
Recommended Item: Whip of Fire

Whip it good!
Snap Judgement? I can see a lot of sex-crazed avatars out there that will use this and abuse this item. I mean, check out my current oufit! I look like a damn bondage master from Hell! Oh well, at least it isn't a multi-quip like the last two months' items.

Cool Whip?
Since both whips are generally the mirror opposite of each other, I'm going to do something different and critique both at the same time.

There are two modes for these little weapons. The first mode is the usual hand-held mode. Here, you can equip one or two in a various combinations. Each position of the hand pretty much gives you a new version of the whips. On the background hand while it is down, the whip is at rest. When brought to the foreground hand, the whip looks to be about ready to strike as it coils from behind your avatar's back and around to the front. Switching back to the background hand in the "held" position, the whip does the same motion as the previous, only this time it comes from the other side. Both of the "fist" positions show a coiled up whip ready for storage or as a warning to would-be slaves and enemies. The last position with the foreground arm out makes you look like you're bringing your whip straight down to give someone a very harsh lashing.

Are you still wondering why I think this item is going to be abused by sexually frustrated users (such as myself)?

The second mode is the same idea but different depending on the item. Both items in their second mode form a tail. This tail is a nice replacement/substitute for the Devil Tail from long ago. It won't bring the price down for questers that much, but it's definately cheaper. The thing is, as far as looks go, you still see the whip wrapped around your avatar. While the Whip of Fire does a better job of supplying a tail, the fact you have to deal with the neck-tie-like handle rather annoys me. I would have rather have it somewhat hidden like with the Whip of Ice. Unfortunately, the Whip of Ice doesn't really form a tail that looks like all the other tails in Gaia. What's different about it? Well, nothing really, except for the fact it is on the opposite side of where it should be.

Whiplash!
Overall, I'm glad they went back to the old "Same item, different modes" system for this month instead of the "It's not only a hat, but a belt and a shirt!" way of the previous months. Yes, you can buy up to four of these whips, but there is really no need for it. Both whips are fairly even, but the Whip of Fire just barely squeaks by since it does a better job of being the sub for the Devil Tail.

In any event, I appreciate Lanzer, VO, and l0cke for going back to the old system of Donation items. But I think this month's item was a mistake. I'm expecting a lot of S&M and BDSM thread to be popping up in the Chatterbox soon (if they haven't already) as a result of this month's items.

Zeek Slider
Community Member
  • [06/16/09 04:09am]
  • [05/16/09 03:36am]
  • [04/16/09 02:05am]
  • [03/16/09 02:19am]
  • [02/16/09 03:35am]
  • [01/15/09 09:42pm]
  • [12/16/08 01:27am]
  • [11/15/08 09:52pm]
  • [10/16/08 01:28am]
  • [09/09/08 01:39am]




  • User Comments: [1]
    Keiosho Murisakin
    Community Member





    Sun Sep 11, 2005 @ 04:40pm


    Oh god I hated the items ever since they came out. I've been HIGHLY disappointed with this years donation items. I loved most of the 04 items and all of the 03 items but the 05 items just suck period. I hated the kiki as well. Everyone wanted it, it was a white ugly looking cat thing that couldn't be put in a comfortable position no matter how you held it that was suitable. Ontop of that it didn't go with too much and really bothered me.

    As for the whips everyone's been using them in the wrong ways and I don't even like them for the fact you can't hold them like a proper whip without it looking odd (I never knew a person could extend their arm and have a whip about to come out with the wrist straight) or just not suiting with anything.

    They have VERY minimal orange items for girls and the pheonix is about the only real thing that matches rather well with it.

    Now in this case, not all of that's true. Thenightdesire's blue avatar is verly lovely with the whip and with the topless glitch, BUT other than that, I've yet to find very many GOOD avatars.


    User Comments: [1]
     
     
    Manage Your Items
    Other Stuff
    Get GCash
    Offers
    Get Items
    More Items
    Where Everyone Hangs Out
    Other Community Areas
    Virtual Spaces
    Fun Stuff
    Gaia's Games
    Mini-Games
    Play with GCash
    Play with Platinum