What Do You Guys Think?

[Elemental Doll]

I'm not sure if I put this in the wrong place or not, forgive me if I did. sweatdrop
Anyway, I need a little help with my avatar. I'm not asking for donations are anything, just your opinion. 3nodding

What do you guys think of this avatar?


And this one..


I'm a big fan of elegant and simple avatars, so what do you think? Should I add more, take some stuff off, etc. ?
Also, any ideas with new avatars? I would like to change mine soon. ^^

 

[asmindys]

I love the second one ^-^

 

[sdrawkcab]

I'm a fan of creativity. I love the style of the second outfit. I think it would be better if you tried to recreate an outfit like that using poses that come from different items. The second one just looks... unoriginal. It doesn't take much thought to make a whole outfit from Noel's Gift items.  

[Daypaw]

♦ ♣ ♥ ♠

I agree with Cabbi. It's easy to make an outfit using poses from the same item- try to create something original using different items and items from different sets.

If you took the second avatar and put it in the arenas, or asked for votes from Avatar Talk regulars, you would unfortunately get an endless stream of flames from people saying that it's uncreative because it's just a set even though it looks nice- because sets are designed to look nice together.

Try, instead, keeping one pose of the Noel (two tops) and then finding other similar colors to build from.

♦ ♣ ♥ ♠

 

[Life Hath Immortality]

The first one is nice.
As for the second, I dislike sets. They take away from the originality of the avi.  

[ChimeBell]

I prefer the first avatar, too. I don't mind, that the second one is a set, I just love the dress.

As for small changes: I would get rid of the yellow ribbon on the second avi. I think it would be better without it.  

[Woutan Kuunsuru]

I agree with Chaim on the ribbon thing.