Am I the only one who thinks BrotherHood sucks?

[celestialokami]

The new voice actors are terrible, for example, Al is a ****ing girl!
The story line is just a mess and doesn't as well put together as the original anime.
But what makes me blood thirsty the most is that Edward and Al's mother isn't a homunculus! They tried to bring her back from the dead, how is she not a homunculus?!
*Screams and goes on a killing rampage* scream
Anyways, whats your opinion?  

[Full Of Envy]

bah i dislike it...  

[_Deadd_Silentt_]

lol inn brotherhood they look... um... different, 'not hot' shall i say.  

[SinfulNekoBot1]

Haven't really seen it yet. Youtube stops loading it halfway through the episode, and it pisses me off, and yeah... D:  

[samuri rocker ninja]

its good somewhat but al sounds too wierd hes a boy not a girl  

[IndigoStarshine]

I only saw like four episodes, but i can't help it, i'm in love and adoration with the original.
new episodes surprised me with how humorous and lighthearted they felt
but maybe it improves?
original will still be my fav though heart whee 3nodding  

[IndigoStarshine]

_Deadd_Silentt_

lol inn brotherhood they look... um... different, 'not hot' shall i say.

i know what you mean, it's really hard for me to get used to it after watching the other for 3 years

i don't like it  

[iBuhnyy]

I liked the original more too, I guess it's becuase the new one has alot more other characters, and it confuses me, lol Im not very smart sweatdrop
iBuhnyy
heart

 

[EveningAlchemist]

The original anime is what got me started, but Brotherhood is based off the manga plot which later on changes and gets too epic to ignore. The animation was off to me too at first, but overall that's not why I'm watching it. Past episode 14 is where it diverges and becomes and completely different anime, just for a note.

P.S. I actually like Maxey Whitehead as Al. At the beginning she was a little girly, but I really appreciate her now. She sounds more identical to the original Japanese VA, and she has the great ability to show emotion in her voice! (Especially noticed that in ep. 5!)  

[Cataberry]

Brotherhood is the way it was meant to be. The original story as Hiromu Arakawa-sensei created it. meaning different reasons for everything. ...And there are a buncha reasons why Al's VA is a girl now. The main one is that the original VA, Aaron Dismuke, hit puberty and that the girl VA is the closest they could get to how he sounded. At least that's what I know.  

[Caro Harrison]

Ed's mom ins't a homunculus because in the new anime, and manga,
homunculi aren't made from human transmutation.  

[Doctor Bullets]

Hey now, I've seen clips of the original FMA anime that even piss ME off. I saw a clip of an old episode where Satera is having the baby. Why are Nina and Lt. Colonel Hughes there? They're supposed to be dead! Where's Winry? Where's Paninya?

See, this is why I read the manga. I want to see Brotherhood now, cuz I hear it'll be more based on the manga.  

[satsukimiura13]

i am cery disappoint... cry  

[EdwardxElricx]

I am sorry to all that i offend, But give it a rest. You that have a prob with brotherhood, read the fricken manga. those that have read the manga, good for you. And those that are going to complain without reading the manga, or watching the original Japanese version, Get over yourselves. they are doing the best with what they have. Any true FMA fan will appreciate all aspects of FMA. (once again, just my opinion)  

[AshleyCarnival]

I have to say that the brotherhood is okay. Al's voice could have been better, but other than that no harm done in my opinion. The brotherhoods art is differnt too...Ed's hair cauht me off guard a bit... sweatdrop The plot is turer to the manga, witch I think is good!
All in All It's not that bad! biggrin