I think anyone who says those type of people deserve to be treated humanely either a rapist, someone who wants to rape, is mentally challenged, and/or is just plain stupid.
Seriously, being raped screws up the rest of your life. I mean, some people are able to move on, but there will still be that fear. Most of 'em completely lose themselves. And they wanna treat the people did that to a person nicely?
I say you outta chemically castrate them, physically castrate them, sew 'em up, and make their life a living hell. If they wanna argue that they changed and that they made a mistake, don't matter. I mean, that person is still gonna be messed up even if the rapist became a saint.
Besides, that's not what you can call a mistake. I mean, you fall asleep while driving and hit a person. That's a mistake. You choose orange juice over apple juice when you wanted apple juice and not orange juice. That's a mistake. Forcing yourself on someone. That's not a mistake. It's freakin' sick.