THE TWINS, WHO IS THE GIRL AND BOY?

[Desdemona Winchcombe]

CherryCain

Kaoru is more girly, and Hikaru is the guy...
but to be honest, i dont care... i wanna do them both XD

I don't mean to be rude but... You do remember that "wanting to do them both" is the one thing that will ensure that you'll do neither of em', right?

I mean apart from the whole fiction thing. D:  

[Ino_Yamanaka_320]

Kaoru has to be the girl
hes always like says "Hikaru!" in a light little girl tone
and Hikaru is the guy cause hes always the one protecting kaoru or being kind of rude  

[Eijay]

Well, they're obviously not actually gay. In their "brotherly love" act though I definitely think that kaoru plays the more feminine, submissive "girl" role why Hikaru is the more dominant "male" character.  

[xXSaint Heizeru Xx]

Hikaru, should be the boy, and Kaoru the girl, Kaoru, even has the same air of maturity that a girl has, but either way, i love them both the same heart mrgreen  

[Totrue-Tufaar]

If they ere homosexual it would be due to fangirls. But they are not. They are brothers. And they like Haruhi. Remember in tha Manga when Tamaki called all the other Hosts gay? They did not take it well. Becasue of that they let him go through a ridiculous routine of pretending to be Haruhi for the check outs hen they already had a plan.  

[- Kadajs Kat -]

Hikaru is the boy and Kaoru was the girl or Hikaru is the seme and Kaoru is the uke...it even makes a reference about that in the 4th episode...when Renge showed up and was having the club film a movie, Hikaru said "How come this stupid script potrays Kaoru as the pitcher?" and then Kaoru says "Yeah."  

[tmhelpimalive]

i would have to say neither of them are "the girl". the right way to say it is seme-dominant and uke-nondominant.

plus, the twincest is an act. in the manga, it actually says that Kaoru IS GAY, but Hikaru isn't *which is why he likes Haruhi.*

end of story.

now if they were to have a twincest, Hikaru would be seme because Kaoru is too sweet and innocent to be seme. hence the fact that Kaoru blushes whenever Hikaru talks about undressing him.  

[Crystal-Jemm]

Oh, honey, it's so obvious!

Kaoru is most definently the uke (girl) and Hikaru is so totally the seme (guy)!  

[Crystal_Music]

karou would be the girl and hikaru would be the guy  

[Eijay]

tmhelpimalive

i would have to say neither of them are "the girl". the right way to say it is seme-dominant and uke-nondominant.

plus, the twincest is an act. in the manga, it actually says that Kaoru IS GAY, but Hikaru isn't *which is why he likes Haruhi.*

end of story.

now if they were to have a twincest, Hikaru would be seme because Kaoru is too sweet and innocent to be seme. hence the fact that Kaoru blushes whenever Hikaru talks about undressing him.

Kaoru? Gay? I was under the impression that they both liked Haruhi, but Kaoru acknowledged that Hikaru loved her more.  

[Xikera Farim]

Kaoru is the "female" to me because he has a softr tone to his voice and has a bit of sorrow in his eyes at times. Hikaru, though is stubborn, is still kind but has a hard edge to the tone of his voice and a harder edge to the way his eyes look at times.  

[zeruhi]

Actually, I would think that Hikaru would be the uke (girl), while Kaoru would be the seme (guy), because Kaoru is more mature, and is sort of more "evil", although he acts really weak, he takes care of Hikaru a lot.  

[cocoa-chan_theinvincible1]

Okay, i don't think they are homo, but i do believe that they are VERY close because they always stuck together in their child hood, but anyways, in the anime, Kaoru is def the girl. But i love 'em both and i wouldn't really care! hee hee heart  

[LazyButler]

I think since Kaoru is calmer and Hikaru is more hot-headed, I think Hikaru would be the guy 3nodding