Welcome to Gaia! ::

A says B lies
B says C lies
C says A and B both lie
Who's telling the truth? Who's lying?

This is a lot easier if you draw a diagram.

These are like, so much easier with a lengthier explanation, but.

C is lying because either A or B have to be telling the truth.

So C and A are lying and B is telling the truth.

I dunno though, it's been forever since one of these has been seen by myself.

Yes, but in a case like this, one must tell the Whole truth, and not a half truth, half lie.

if we go logically, since B was accused of lying twice, i say B is lying

if we go by movie logic, then all three are lying and the butler did it

if we go by Jack Sparrow logic, it doesn't matter who lied or not. it only matters that a distrustful person is more trustful than a trustful person, because with a distrustful person, you can always trust that they are being distrustful, but you cant trust a trustful person for their trust may be half trust therefore not the whole trust making them distrustful in which case you can trust that the distrustful trustful person is being distrustful and only halfway trustful...

...the butler did it

I would say that B is lying.

My sister says that C is lying.

My father doesn't give a s*it about some stupid riddle.

A lawyer says that his client is innocent.

Sherlock Holmes says that the butler did it.

Matlock says that the waitor did it.

Hercule Poirot says that it was D, who framed B to look like guilty.

Mario says: "It's-a me, Mario!"

Jack Sparrow is wondering why is all the rum gone.

Billy Mays says that the liar is B. And that's not all!...

And a guy is 4chan is wondering whether anyone of them has really been far even as decided to use even go want to do look more like.

A says B lies and so does C so B is lieing.
C says A and B lied and B said C lied but B lied so its not C who lied. C is the correct answer. A lot of people know this and it's 75% that I am correct. If you would like me to join this guild can you plz post HARDER questions? rolleyes