Open Forum or Guild Roleplay

[JackLaen]

When I say Open forum, I don't mean anyone can post at random, of course they would have to have a character which was already pre-approved by me.

When I say guild, well its obvious enough, a guild people would apply to, join in on, and then we would all Rp in there, however that isnt well liked by many and is a bit harder on them.

In order to decide im putting up this poll, but I will make the final decision of course.  

[Cheese Frog]

In my experience, forum rps tend to last much longer than guild rps. They tend to have more people who join even further into the story, but they do tend to be messy. However, messiness isn't exactly the issue. Everything will eventually fall into place in a forum rp, whereas in a guild rp, more people will just stop getting involved. This is why I'm more in favor of a forum rp.  

[JackLaen]

Yeah, thats why im leaning more towards it.  

[xXtea_for_the_hatterXx]

I vote forum rp for the same reasons as Cheese Frog. I also have a lot more experience with them.